The short answer

Live polling tools such as Mentimeter let every student answer a question on their own device, and show the results to the room straight away. Used well, they turn a lecture into a conversation: you find out what students already know, check what they have understood, and hear from people who would never put a hand up.

Used badly, they become a gimmick. The tool is not what makes the difference. The question you ask, and what you do with the answers, is.

A simple three-question pattern

You do not need many polls. Three well-placed questions in a session are enough to start with.

  1. An opening question. Ask something that reveals what students already think or know. A prediction works well: “What do you think this chart will show?” It gets everyone thinking before you explain anything.
  2. A mid-session check. After a key idea, ask one question that tests whether it has landed. If most students get it wrong, you know to go back over it before moving on. This is the biggest practical gain for the teacher.
  3. A closing question. Ask for the one thing that is still unclear, or the one thing they will use. An open-ended question with a word cloud or a short list of answers is quick to read and gives you something to start the next session with.

Choosing the right question type

  • Multiple choice for checking understanding. Write the wrong answers so that each one reveals a specific misunderstanding.
  • Open-ended or word cloud for opinions, ideas and questions. Read a few answers aloud and respond to them.
  • Scales for confidence (“How confident are you with this?”) and for opinions you want to compare.
  • Ranking when you want students to prioritise, which suits business cases and decisions.

Before the session: a checklist

  • Test the join process on your own phone, in the room, on the real screen. Display the join code or QR code large and leave it up for a minute.
  • Have a backup. If the Wi-Fi or the screen fails, know what you will do instead, such as a show of hands or a printed question.
  • Offer another way to respond. Not every student has a charged device or a data connection. Let students share a device or answer verbally.
  • Think about accessibility. Read each question aloud, avoid answers that depend on colour alone, and leave enough time for students who use assistive technology.
  • Be careful about privacy. Check what your session settings record about participants before you tell students their answers are anonymous. Do not ask for personal details, and check your university’s policy on third-party tools.
  • Check your plan. Free plans have limits that change from time to time, so look at Mentimeter’s own plans page and ask whether your university already has a licence.

Common mistakes

  • Asking, then moving on. If you do not respond to the results, students learn that their answers do not matter.
  • Trivial questions. A question with an obvious answer wastes time. A good question has at least two answers that a thoughtful student might choose.
  • Time pressure on everything. Speed-based quizzes can be fun, but they reward fast typing over careful thinking. Save them for review sessions.
  • Treating the results as a test. Unless it is a deliberate quiz, say that the poll is for learning and not for marks.

What the research says

There is a good deal of research on audience response systems in general, including the older “clickers”, and a growing body on Mentimeter in particular. The picture is encouraging, but it is not as strong as the enthusiasm around the tool can make it sound.

  • Students tend to like it. A study drawing on 204 student survey responses looked at the effect on student satisfaction, enjoyment, voice and learning in small and large groups across several disciplines (Mayhew et al., 2020).
  • It can improve attention and interaction. A study with 400 students and 12 academics found improved attention, engagement, collaborative learning and interaction, and found that immediate feedback let teachers monitor learning and adjust (Pichardo et al., 2021).
  • A single session can help. An action research study with one cohort of third-year occupational therapy students found that Mentimeter enhanced engagement and learning in that session, which is a small and specific finding (Webb, 2022).
  • Good practice matters. Reviews of earlier response systems gather best-practice advice and discuss both the benefits and the challenges of using them (Caldwell, 2007; Kay and LeSage, 2009).
  • The learning gains are less certain. A review of clickers in the biosciences found mixed evidence on exam marks. The authors concluded that clickers appear to help students learn concepts, but said the case is less clear for analytical tasks and for postgraduate courses, and that robust evidence on academic performance is still scarce (Lopez et al., 2014).

A fair reading is that live polling is liked by students and gives teachers useful feedback, while the evidence for better results is mixed, and weaker still for postgraduate teaching. Much of the Mentimeter-specific research relies on student surveys and single courses, so it shows what students felt more than what they learned.

References

  • Caldwell, J. E. (2007). Clickers in the large classroom: current research and best-practice tips. CBE Life Sciences Education. https://www.lifescied.org/doi/10.1187/cbe.06-12-0205
  • Kay, R. H. and LeSage, A. (2009). Examining the benefits and challenges of using audience response systems: a review of the literature. Computers and Education, 53, 819 to 827.
  • Mayhew, E., Davies, M., Millmore, A., Thompson, L. and Pena Bizama, A. (2020). The impact of audience response platform Mentimeter on the student and staff learning experience. Research in Learning Technology, 28. https://doi.org/10.25304/rlt.v28.2397
  • Lopez, J. A., Love, C. and Watters, D. (2014). Clickers in biosciences: do they improve academic performance? International Journal of Innovation in Science and Mathematics Education, 22(3), 26 to 41. https://openjournals.library.sydney.edu.au/CAL/article/view/7118/8353
  • Pichardo, J. I., López-Medina, E. F. and colleagues (2021). Students and teachers using Mentimeter: technological innovation to face the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic and post-pandemic in higher education. Education Sciences. https://doaj.org/article/3da8933cf4c64a67a01f846b8168c61d
  • Webb, S. (2022). Can Mentimeter enhance university student participation in taught sessions? International Journal of Higher Education Pedagogies, 3(4), 1 to 12. https://doi.org/10.33422/ijhep.v3i4.72

This guide is shared under CC BY 4.0 . You're welcome to reuse it in your own teaching with credit to Surabil.
Suggested credit: Surabil, “A practical guide to using Mentimeter in lectures”, https://surabil.com/guides/using-mentimeter-in-lectures/, licensed under CC BY 4.0.